
Student debt cuts first-time buyers' borrowing power by more than 25,000 euro
If you go looking for a home with a student loan behind you, you notice it fairly quickly in the adviser's sums. On an income of 60,000 euro, a repayment of one hundred euro a month costs more than 25,000 euro in borrowing power. In a market where young buyers already struggle to get a foot in, that is an amount that can decide whether you can join the bidding at all.
The number of first-time buyers is falling. Among young people in particular the share buying a home is dropping, and student debt plays an increasingly visible part in that. Lenders treat the loan as a financial commitment, just like a car lease or a personal loan. "People with a student loan usually repay a monthly amount. That affects how much money you have available each month, so you can borrow less than you could without the debt," says Marga Lankreijer-Kos, mortgage expert at comparison site Independer.
Not the debt, but the monthly payment
The rules have shifted in recent years. Before 2024, banks looked at the original or the outstanding student loan. Since that year the monthly amount is central: what you actually transfer to the student finance agency each month.
That helps anyone who has been repaying steadily for years. Your accumulated repayment counts, because a lower remaining balance means a lower monthly instalment. But it also makes the calculation less intuitive. Two people with exactly the same student debt can have very different borrowing power, simply because their repayment terms run differently.
For young buyers it is not the total student debt but the monthly payment that determines the mortgage available.The surcharge you do not see on your statement
There is another layer in the calculation that surprises many buyers. Banks apply a surcharge factor that moves with the mortgage rate. At a rate of 3.9 percent, a monthly payment of one hundred euro is treated in the calculation as 120 euro. The higher the rate, the heavier that surcharge weighs.
The logic behind it is defensible. A higher rate means higher housing costs, so every other commitment is weighted more heavily. To the buyer it feels less logical, because the amount you pay the student finance agency does not change.
What it costs in practice
Independer worked it out for a household on an income of 60,000 euro buying a home with energy label C. At a rate of 3.9 percent, someone without student debt can borrow a maximum of 270,116 euro. With a repayment of one hundred euro a month, 244,674 euro of that remains.
If the rate rises to 5.5 percent, the maximum mortgage with student debt falls to 230,585 euro, against 254,361 euro without. The difference is then almost 24,000 euro.
And something stands out there. The rule of thumb says student debt weighs more heavily at a higher rate, but in these figures the absolute difference actually shrinks: from more than 25,000 euro at 3.9 percent to almost 24,000 euro at 5.5 percent. In percentage terms the effect stays roughly the same, around nine percent of your maximum mortgage. The surcharge factor does rise, but the total it is applied to falls faster. So if you were worried that a rate rise would make your student debt hurt twice, you can put that fear into perspective. The rate rise itself is the problem, not the weighting of the debt.
On an income of 60,000 euro, one hundred euro of monthly repayment costs about nine percent of the maximum mortgage.Putting off repayment does not help
One misconception that comes up regularly, according to Lankreijer-Kos: the idea that your student debt does not count as long as you are not yet repaying. "Even if you are not paying anything yet, it is important when calculating a mortgage to state what you would have to pay if you were repaying. A mortgage is long-term planning."
Logical, when you think about it. A mortgage runs for thirty years; the grace period on your student loan lasts a few. The bank looks at the situation that lasts longest.
Not on the credit register, but you must declare it
A student loan is not recorded at the national credit register. That sometimes leads to the conclusion that the bank does not know about it and you can leave it out. That does not work. You are obliged to declare the debt in your application, and concealing it is risky.
Bank statements simply show the monthly payment to the student finance agency. If it comes to light later, withholding it can be treated as fraud, with consequences that reach far beyond a rejected application.
A student loan is not on the credit register, but declaring it is compulsory in every mortgage application.What first-time buyers can do with this
The sum that follows is interesting. If one hundred euro of monthly payment costs around 25,000 euro in borrowing power, paying off extra student debt can increase your purchasing power on the housing market. Clear the debt entirely and the monthly payment disappears, and with it the deduction from your borrowing capacity. Anyone who puts in 15,000 euro of savings and gets 25,000 euro of borrowing power back is ahead in total purchasing power.
But that is not an automatic win. Those savings could also have gone towards transfer tax, buyer's costs or a renovation, and you cannot add those to the mortgage. On top of that, the interest on student loans is low for many cohorts compared with what a mortgage costs. So work it through with an adviser before you empty your buffer.
There is also some good news. The supply of homes for sale is at a record high and the market is cooling. For first-time buyers, that wider choice and the calmer bidding may weigh more heavily than the 25,000 euro their student debt costs them in borrowing power. The question is no longer only how much you can borrow, but whether you still have to outbid ten other people.
For agents and advisers the practical lesson is mainly that student debt has to be on the table early. Not in the last week before the offer, but in the first conversation. It spares buyers a disappointment that a simple question could have prevented.
What does this mean for you?
The market differs per neighbourhood and per month. In a consultation we look at what the news means for your plans to buy or sell.